Monthly Archives: July 2026

Thomas Arne: The Periodical Overture in 8 Parts – XXVII (The Guardian Outwitted)

 

With the twenty-seventh issue of the Periodical Overtures, announced in early April 1770, publisher Robert Bremner (1725–1789) [1] did something he had never done before: he printed a symphony by an English composer, Thomas Augustine Arne (1717–1778). True, the Scot Thomas Alexander Erskine (the Earl of Kelly) had been featured three times up to this point, contributing Periodical Overtures Nos. 13, 17, and 25. Arne, however, appeared only this one time in the series, and while Erskine would figure once again—in fact, in the subsequent issue, Periodical Overture No. 28—no other British composers were represented in the sixty-one symphonies.

The inclusion of Arne’s piece was itself a bit surprising, even though Arne had been a long-standing and prominent musical figure in Great Britain. When his comic opera The Guardian Outwitted premiered at the Theatre Royal, Covent Garden, on 12 December 1764, it lasted only six nights.[2] Ironically, a string of critiques—some in prose, and some as satirical odes—were published over the next several weeks, persisting much longer than the opera itself.[3] Despite the production’s relatively brief run, Bremner published a vocal score (with Arne’s dedication to Queen Charlotte) early in 1765, containing songs and duets along with a keyboard arrangement of the overture.[4] It was that same overture—some five years later—that would comprise Periodical Overture No. 27.

Thomas Arne (1717-1789) The Periodical Overture in 8 Parts – No. XXVII

Key: G | Movements: 3 (1) Con Spirito (2) Andante Larghetto (3) Andante Amoroso Duration: 5:43 Scoring: 2 oboes, 2 flutes, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 violins, viola, basso Originally published by Robert Bremner, London, 1770 (RISM A.1834)

Purchase the score and performance materials:

https://repertoire-explorer.musikmph.de/product-category/special-editions/periodical-overtures-edition/

From the Preface to the printed edition: It is easy to argue that the overture of The Guardian Outwitted is a very fine introductory piece for listeners who are new to Arne. He demonstrates his awareness of changing trends in theater overtures, since he incorporates several of the structural elements of stand-alone concert symphonies, such as the shift from G major in the outer movements to the parallel minor for the central “Andante Larghetto.” Like members of the Mannheim school, he gives significant attention to the winds; he also expands the ensemble from Bremner’s customary “eight parts” by requiring flutes in the finale and a pair of bassoons throughout.

The opening “Con Spirito” seems to reflect a composer who was straddling the divide between the Ancients (those who valued the traditions of Baroque music) and the Moderns (fans of the newest compositional trends). This first movement presents a blend of older overture conventions with newer symphonic techniques, such as its proto-sonata-rondo form. Arne’s first theme is full of sudden contrasts: it opens with a full-ensemble hammer-blow and then immediately shifts to delicate, piano, staccato notes in the upper strings; the full group re-enters at a forte for six measures until returning to the opening material. This time, though, the six-measure passage is expanded to eight bars, and it transitions to the dominant minor for the movement’s lyrical second theme at measure 19. This theme—with its “real harmonic character”—features the oboes, who play conjunct pairs of notes in alternation with small flurries of sixteenths in the violins.[5] After this brief four-bar passage, the full ensemble returns to the first theme at measure 23, now in the dominant major. Arne does not repeat the exposition; instead, the first theme launches the development at measure 31, while it is the second theme that heralds the return to the tonic G (m. 60), but again, in the parallel minor. Four measures later, the first theme solidifies the sense of closure with its robust scoring in G major.

In contrast to the numerous modern features of the first movement, the tiny ten-measure “Andante Larghetto” resembles the slow “bridge” transitions between movements in Baroque structures such as concertos and trio sonatas. It differs significantly from the keyboard reduction in the older vocal score, and it is unknown which version more accurately represents the overture actually performed in Covent Garden. In any event, the simpler rhythmic passages in the Periodical Overture provide a clearer showcase for the orchestral timbral effects. The oboes take the lead, while the strings play pizzicato until the final two bars. The movement culminates with a fermata in measure 8 that suggests an opportunity for a brief cadenza (and which was specified in the keyboard version). The oboes then fall silent and the strings play an arco half-cadence, pausing on D major before an implied attacca into the finale.

The “Andante Amoroso” does not evoke the “gigue” finales heard in the majority of Bremner’s Periodical Overtures. Instead, it suggests a different, more sedate dance, such as a minuet or even a Ländler. It contains three themes in an a-a-b-a-c-b-c-a pattern. While the quiet first theme (a) puts an emphasis on beat 2 with its opening quarter-note/half-note rhythms and prevalent rinforzandi, it starts to introduce Scotch snaps in measure 5, and these quickly prove to be a dominant feature throughout the finale. The first violin often bypasses steps four and seven in the scale (as in, for example, measure 5), giving those passages a pentatonic flavour. The b theme (m. 17) then features the Scotch snap in almost every bar, while the c motif (m. 32) reduces but does not eliminate the distinctive folk rhythm. All through the movement, the strings and woodwinds are showcased in alternation. Moreover, the bassoon takes on an independent role—the first extended example of this type of scoring to appear in Bremner’s series. The overall effect is charming; it is also an ample illustration of Arne’s “God-gifted” melodic expertise.

Alyson McLamore

[1] Bremner’s birth year differs from the “c.1713” currently listed in most published sources; it is based on information from Scottish baptismal records that was kindly conveyed to us by Rudolf Rasch.

[2] “London Stage Event: 12 December 1764 at Covent Garden,” London Stage Database, accessed April 8, 2026, https://londonstagedatabase.uoregon.edu/event.php?id=32448.

[3] P.C. Roscoe, “Arne and ‘The Guardian Outwitted,” Music & Letters 24, no. 4 (Oct. 1943): 239–244.

[4] British Library, G.230.(2).

[5] Richard Platt, “Thomas Augustine Arne, 1710–1778,” in The Symphony and Overture in Great Britain: Twenty Works, ed. Richard Platt, Susan Kirakowska, David Johnson, and Thomas McIntosh, Series E, Volume I of The Symphony, 1720–1840 (New York: Garland, 1984), lxvi.

Jacob Herschel: The Periodical Overture in 8 Parts – XXVI

In the first twenty-five issues of the Periodical Overtures, publisher Robert Bremner (c.1725–1789) had issued a small handful of works by composers living in (or visiting) Great Britain. This direct contact had certainly been the case with the inaugural symphony by Johann Christian Bach (1735–1782), and Bach—still resident in London—had been represented again (less happily) by Periodical Overture No. 15. Bremner’s personal acquaintance with Thomas Alexander Erskine (1732–1781), the sixth Earl of Kelly, clearly had led to the publication of Periodical Overtures Nos. 13, 17, and the most recent issue, No. 25, which appeared in June 1769. It seems quite possible that Bremner also had contracted in person for the right to publish the twenty-sixth symphony in the series, since its composer—Jacob Herschel (1734–1792)—is known to have spent various periods of time in London during a two-year stay in England; in fact, his sojourn in Great Britain did not end until late July 1769, while Bremner’s print was issued just four months later.

Jacob Herschel (1734-1792) The Periodical Overture in 8 Parts – No. XXVI

Key: C | Movements: 3 (1) Allegro con brio (2) Andante molto più tosto Allegretto (3) Presto Duration: 7:42 Scoring: 2 violins, viola, basso, 2 oboes, 2 horns Originally published by Robert Bremner, London, 1769 (RISM H.5194)

Purchase the score and peroformance materials:

https://repertoire-explorer.musikmph.de/product-category/special-editions/periodical-overtures-edition/

From the Preface to the printed edition: As the sole published symphonic music by (Jacob) Herschel—and perhaps the first music of any sort by Herschel in modern edition—Periodical Overture No. 26 presents a very fine calling card. The first movement lives up to its “Allegro con brio” designation with a bold premier coup d’archet in which the full ensemble plays a two-measure unison triadic figure to cement the tonic C major. After these hammerstrokes and several rising and falling scalar lines, the first violins perform an extended descending sequential pattern, supported by measured tremolos and “drum 8ths” in the lower strings. In measure 17, Herschel launches the first of several playful passages in which the first violins rapidly repeat a single pitch at a piano dynamic for two bars before crescendoing to forte. During that quiet passage, however, the violins are interrupted multiple times by the rest of the ensemble who interject quick forte appoggiaturas. After a similar interplay starting at measure 28 (now in G major), the movement takes an unexpected turn to the dominant minor to launch the “B” section (m. 38) of the movement’s ternary form. During this mostly piano passage, Herschel again startles listeners with subito interjections of an ensemble fortissimo (m. 45, m. 53). At measure 74, a return of the dynamic interchange first heard in measure 17 is our cue that a reprise of the “A” section is near, and the opening hammerstrokes make their reappearance at measure 91.

The second movement of Periodical Overture No. 26 mixes conventional and unconventional elements. The drop to a slower tempo and the omission of the winds are both expected, but the “Andante molto più tosto Allegretto” designation is unusually detailed. The change, harmonically, to F major—the subdominant of C major—is a standard transition, but the repetition scheme of ||: a :||: b a :|| c a || is a bit unexpected, expanding what initially seems to be an ordinary rounded-binary structure into a form that might be best described as a rondo. Herschel sets each melody apart, opening the refrain (a) with a five-note ascent (with a bit of chromaticism) that then gradually works its way downward above a busily “seesaw” pattern in Violin II. The b episode, in F’s dominant key, C major, descends more directly, first in sequential three-note groups, and then in a longer scale. The c episode—in d minor—shifts to much longer (and louder) quarter-note values in most of the ensemble; their four-note descents expand on the three-note descents of b.

Herschel’s sense of humour seems to be in evidence yet again in the “Presto,” written in a gigue-like meter. As in the first movement, the full ensemble bounces its way through a rising C major arpeggio as a premier coup d’archet—but when the ensemble catches its collective breath on the fourth beat of the measure, the violins quickly fill the silence with racing eighth notes. This lively gimmick is repeated in the second bar and again at many points during the movement. The finale employs two main melodies, a and b, that progress through the tonic and dominant harmonies in an || a/I b/V a/V b/I || pattern. James Hepokoski and Warren Darcy have labeled this structure as a “Type 2 Sonata”; Herschel’s version does not contain the repetition that often divides the form in half.1 In contrast to the a theme with its opening disjunct bounciness, the b melody (m. 11 and m. 50) starts with rising and falling conjunct eighth notes that are occasionally interrupted by a large upward leap. Herschel also interjects short “block-chord” passages, such as measure 16—rather like the c episode in the slow movement—that underpin an effervescent melody in the first violin. In contrast to the flexible dynamics during the preceding movements, the finale sustains a robust forte or fortissimo throughout. Altogether, Periodical Overture No. 26 gives listeners an exhilarating—but regrettably rare—illustration of Herschel’s ample capabilities.

Alyson McLamore

1 James Hepokoski and Warren Darcy, Elements of Sonata Theory: Norms, Types, and Deformations in the Late-Eighteenth-Century Sonata (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006), 353–4.